Skip to main content

 

God and the monarchy.

Charles III, like all his predecessors, bases his claim for legitimacy not on the will of the people but on a special relationship with God. Are we still okay with that?

Out of sight, Charles (with a dab of special oil) officially becomes king

When Charles III ceremonially became king at his coronation in 2023, he promised to remain “a faithful Protestant”. Without that promise, he could not have become king.

 It’s the law, and has been since 1689. Although times have changed and Britain is now a very different country, the basis of the monarchy’s claim of legitimacy remains the same. It’s  foundation is not the will of the people but the will of God. If you thought the Divine Right of Kings died with Charles I in 1649, think again.

Coronation ceremonies are designed to look ancient even when they’re not: the aura of tradition and time lends credibility to the claim of legitimacy. The Archbishop of Canterbury anointed the new(ish) king with oil (called chrism) that had been made and consecrated in Jerusalem from olives harvested on the Mount of Olives. It was blessed by the Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem and the Anglican Archbishop of Jerusalem.

When the chrism was smeared on Charles in the form of a cross, it was – according to the dogma – the most mysterious and potent legitimisation of his reign, a direct line from God. It was so sacred and secret that the ceremony had to take place behind specially-designed screens.

It seems extraordinary that, in the second quarter of the 21st century, such flim-flam is required to make someone the head of state in modern democratic countries such as Britain, Australia and Canada. Charles is our king, and our head of state, too.

“A good Protestant” does not mean a Presbyterian or a Methodist. It means an Anglican, an adherent of the Church of England: an outfit that owes its foundation to a king who, in 1534, wanted a new wife. Henry VIII not only got his divorce: in the process, he made himself the head of the nation’s only lawful religion.

But according to the latest census data, less than half the population of England and Wales call themselves Christian. In a single decade (to 2021) their numbers fell from 59% of the population to 46%. Over the same period, non-belief boomed.

Figures from the authoritative British Social Attitudes survey are even more striking. Its 2019 report found the proportion of Britons who identify as Christian fell from 66% in 1983 to 38% in 2019. And only 12% identified as Anglican. That means that King Charles governs on the basis of 8.3 million in a total UK population of 70 million.

According to the latest report: “Today, more than half (52%) do not see themselves as belonging to any religion, and two-thirds never attend ordinary religious services Increasingly, the non-religious are confidently atheist, with a quarter of the public now stating “I do not believe in God” compared to just 10% in 1998.”

There’s a similar shift in Australia. In all states – and most emphatically in Tasmania – Christianity is losing followers to “no religion”. On a percentage basis “other” religions are also doing well, but off of a much smaller base.

The fall in Christian adherence mirrors a similar decline in support for the monarchy: still a majority, but a declining one.

Support for a British republic is strongly correlated with age: younger people are more likely to favour it, though support in all age groups remains well below 50%.

It’s a different picture in Australia, where ditching the monarchy remains the most popular preferred option. There is evidence, though, that as people think more about the subject, support for the monarchy increases. The “undecideds” who later make a decision have almost all opted for the monarchy.

The British monarchy is more popular in Canada. According to the Ipsos surveys, just over half of Canadians agree that “the constitutional monarchy helps to define Canadian identity and should continue to be our form of government”. There are two potential reasons for this: the need for Canadians to differentiate themselves from the behemoth to the south, and the visit of King Charles in 2025.

The relative enthusiasm in Canada for the British monarchy is even harder to reconcile with the nation’s religious and cultural structure. There are two official languages – English and French – reflecting the occasionally strained relationship between Ontario and Quebec which is reflected in durable Catholic adherence, particularly among French-Canadians. But in just ten years, the picture changed dramatically, with the proportion of non-believers soaring. Even Catholics are leaving their religion behind.

Religious decline is evident throughout the developed world: almost everywhere in Europe and the Americas and in much of Asia. That downward trend is much more pronounced than the return to religion that’s taking place in Africa.

Why are they still there?

At its most fundamental level, the royal claim of legitimacy rests not on the will of the people but on the magical properties of olive oil and its pathway to God. Most of us no longer believe in those mysteries but our unelected, hereditary sovereigns remain in place. So too do their still-considerable powers and wealth.

According to a briefing paper from the House of Lords, the monarch has the power to (among other unspecified functions):

  • appoint a prime minister;
  • summon or prorogue Parliament;
  • give or refuse royal assent to bills;
  • legislate by prerogative orders in council or by letters patent;
  • exercise the prerogative of mercy, e.g. to pardon convicted offenders;
  • make treaties;
  • wage war by any means and to make peace;
  • recognise states;
  • issue passports and to provide consular services;
  • confer honours, decorations and peerages; and
  • make certain appointments, including royal commissions.

Those powers, by extension, are also given to governors and governors-general. It is a convention that the monarch can act only on the advice of the relevant prime minister, but that’s a convention only. It’s not law, and it doesn’t appear in the Australian or Canadian constitutions. There is, of course, no written British constitution: it’s entirely convention.

It’s also a convention in all three countries that a government can continue in power while it retains the confidence of the “lower” house of parliament. The weakness of that convention was shown clearly in Australia in 1975, when the Governor-General, Sir John Kerr, with the knowledge of the Queen, dismissed the elected Labor government of Gough Whitlam. Kerr became a pariah in much of the country, but there was no legal recourse. A convention had been broken, not the law.

The royal family does not represent a financial cost to Australia or Canada except when they are in the country. Charles was in Canada for only 24 hours during his 2025 visit but that single day cost Canadian taxpayers at least $C2.6 million ($US1.8 million, $A2.7 million). That included $870,000 for a ceremonial air force flyover, nearly $860,000 in police expenses and close to $370,000 for air and ground transport.

The king could have paid for it himself. He’s rich enough: Forbes has estimated the wealth of the royal family at £21.3 billion ($US28 billion). That’s separate from Charles’s personal wealth of at £1.8 billion ($US2.4 billion). It’s also separate from the Crown Estate, a vast property empire.

The Sovereign Grant – a posh name for the royal weekly wage – comes from British taxpayers and in 2026-27 amounted to £21.5 million ($US28.45 million).

Compared with the costs of running the country, that’s small change. But it sharpens the question: if the king costs so much, and has so many remaining, hidden powers, why isn’t he elected?


Popular posts

  Loss of vision. Australia’s leaders forgot how to lead. When Paul Keating moved out of the Prime Ministerial Lodge in Canberra on 21 March 1996 after showing John Howard around, a period of reform and vision ended and a new era of Australian political history began.
  It shouldn’t be this hard. For most of this century, standards of living for ordinary people have been going backwards. This isn’t how it’s supposed to be .
  God is not dead. Yet. Most of the world is turning away from religion. Australia leads the pack.
  An age of discontent. Change is happening faster than human society can adjust. Discontent, disorder and alienation are the result.
  After Trump, a fairer world? At noon on 20 January 2029, Donald Trump will no longer be president of the United States. What happens then?
A lovely day in Dystopia. What sort of world do the far-right populists want to create? And what do their billionaire backers want for their money?
  The global oil crisis that wasn’t. Closing the Strait of Hormuz was supposed to cripple economies worldwide. It didn’t. Why?
  Out of chaos, hope Everywhere, democratic politics is in turmoil. When the confusion recedes, only the progressives will remain standing.
  How to lose a war. History has many lessons about wars and how to lose them. Trump’s latest dismal escapade shows how completely he has failed to learn.
Which state has the worst hospitals? Let’s get one thing straight. No state actually has good hospitals. The whole system has been too neglected and too poorly resourced for too long.